Comments: In April, 2003 I purchased
a raw 1939 Play Ball Averill on eBay for around a hundred bucks.
It was an upgrade to a PSA 3 I purchased just a few days earlier.
Both were sold when I upgraded to a SGC 86 in July 2005 after
another eBay purchase. Somewhere along the line I found a picture
of a 1928 Exhibits PCL card on some chat room or auction site.
I knew the Play Ball card was just a temporary placeholder until
I could get my hands on one. The opportunity for an affordable
example came up on 5/19/2011 in a Mile High Card Company auction.
It was described:
"The key card in the issue, this Hall of Famer is depicted
in a portrait style image, free of distractions and hindered only
by its coupon corner being clipped off for redemption purposes,
and the sole reason for its assessment of Authentic."
In September, 2011 I found this raw example on eBay. Even with
the pencil writing on the back, it should grade GOOD and prove
me with an upgrade to the clipped corner exampe described above.
UPDATE: In Nov, 2013 I included this card in a submission using
a 15-free gradings voucher I received from PSA for joining their
Collectors Club. With the writing on the reverse I knew it would
get a qualifier, but was expecting a GOOD rating. Very happy to
get a VG grade instead - received back from PSA on 12/11/2013!
I wouldn't mind upgrading this one too - wish me luck. Here it is (note the blank back compared to the coupon back on the SGC 60):
UPDATE: The Summer 2016 Love of the Game auction included several items of interest – a 1928 Exhibits PCL Averill SGC 45, a 1922 Exhibits Cy Rigler SGC 60, and a 1928 Sweetman Paul Waner SGC 30. I had owned a Sweetman card a long time ago, sold it, and then realized it’s scarcity afterwards. This triggered the desire to re-acquire another example. I wanted all three cards but had a weekend getaway to the mountains planned. So, I placed several Max Bids not knowing if I’d have wireless signal from the campsite. On the evening of 6/11 a thunderstorm hit Mueller State Park and the family was tucked in to our sleeping bags while it rained outside. My cell phone reception was perfect and I had three bars – monitoring the auction would not be an issue while the other family members slept. My bids held up and I won all three cards. Two were upgrades – Averill (from a PSA 3 MK) and Rigler (from a SGC 40), and one was a newbie for me – the Sweetman Waner. It completed my 1928 Ice Cream run as I already had W502, Tharps and Harringtons represented in the collection. I was ecstatic about the Averill. My other copy didn’t have the coupon on the reverse and the pencil writing was annoying. It was a great upgrade.